How do season 4's episodes rank?

[You-Know-Who]

Here's my list:

1 - The Constant
2 - The Shape of Things to Come
3 - Cabin Fever
4 - There's No Place Like Home (Parts 1, 2, and 3)
5 - Confirmed Dead
6 - The Economist
7 - Meet Kevin Johnson
8 - The Beginning of the End
9 - The Other Woman
10 - Something Nice Back Home
11 - Ji Yeon
12 - Eggtown


I will update it as new episodes air or I change my mind.

Everyone, post your episode rankings!

[You-Know-Who]

bump

[Perry]

My list would be fairly similar:

1 - The Constant (Crazy)
2 - The Shape of Things to Come (Awesome Smokey & Ben & Widmore)
3 - The Other Woman (Gotta love the Ben & Juliet stuff)
4 - Confirmed Dead (Jam-packed ep)
5 - The Economist (Timers & Ben/Sayid set-up)
6 - The Beginning of the End (Jacob/Christian, Abaddon & Charlie)
7 - Meet Kevin Johnson (Fill-in of mostly obvious occurrences)
8 - Something Nice Back Home (This episode is just lucky there are worse ones. Oh, and Kate's hot ass)
9 - Eggtown (Stupid Locke, stupid laws and I called Aaron so that reveal did nothing for me)
10 - Ji Yeon (Even looking at the Lostpedia entry, this episode did ABSOLUTELY nothing! wow Jin may be dead, Michael finally shows up, we get told the obvious that it is Charles' boat, Bernard and Jin go fishing and Jin buys a fucking panda! Useless)

[Justin]

1. There's No Place Like Home, Parts 2&3
2. The Beginning of the End
3. Confirmed Dead
4. The Economist
5. Cabin Fever
6. There's No Place Like Home, Part 1
7. The Other Woman
8. The Shape of Things to Come
9. Something Nice Back Home
10. Meet Kevin Johnson
11. The Constant
12. Ji Yeon
13. Eggtown

[David3]

1 The Shape of Things to Come.
2 The Beginning of the End
3 The Constant
4 Confirmed Dead
5 Meet Kevin Johnson
6 The Economist
7 Something Nice Back Home
8 The Other Woman
9 Ji Yeon
10 Eggtown

[You-Know-Who]

This is for my own future reference:

1. The Beginning of the End
2. Confirmed Dead
3. The Economist
4. The Other Woman
5. The Shape of Things to Come
6. Something Nice Back Home
7. Meet Kevin Johnson
8. The Constant
9. Ji Yeon
.
.
.
13. Eggtown

Haaahah! Poor eggtown... :)

[David3]

updated 5/30/08...

1 No Place Like Home (Parts 2-3)
2 The Shape of Things to Come
3 Cabin Fever
4 Confirmed Dead
5 The Constant
6 No Place Like Home (Part 1)
7 Meet Kevin Johnson
8 The Beginning of the End
9 The Economist
10 Something Nice Back Home
11 The Other Woman
12 Ji Yeon
13 Eggtown

[You-Know-Who]

David and anyone else... you don't have to make a new post when you revise or add things to your list. There should be an edit button to the top right of your post.

[Stephen]

By length of podcast:

1: Cabin Fever
2: Meet Kevin Johnson
3: Confirmed Dead
4: Ji Yeon
5: The Economist
6: The Shape of Things to Come
7: The Other Woman
8: Eggtown
9: The Constant
10: The Beginning of the End
11: Something Nice Back Home

[Justin]

I like that our longest and shortest podcasts were in successive weeks

[Perry]

I know everyone keeps saying Eggtown was the worst, but I think it's just something that people are blindly jumping on board with. I think it is clearly the 2nd worst episode. If you disagree can you please explain to me how Ji Yeon is not the worst episode?

[You-Know-Who]

Ji Yeon has all kinds of cool stuff going on on the freighter. Eggtown doesn't.

[Perry]

Ji Yeon has all kinds of cool stuff going on on the freighter. Eggtown doesn't.

Freighter events:
Frank gives Sayid and Desmond lima beans
They hear a knocking
Regina jumps off
We get told info we knew about Widmore
We see a blood stain
We "find out" that Michael is there

Boring to me.

As I said, I know Eggtown is bad, but Ji Yeon is a waste of space.

[You-Know-Who]

The info we get about Widmore is important. It's interesting to hear both sides of the story regarding the fake plane crash. Also, don't forget that we learned the Jin was supposedly dead. I agree that Ji Yeon is not that much better than Eggtown, I would say they're pretty much tied, in the same way that The Economist and The Beginning of the End are tied for me.

[TheRadioTower]

1. Cabin Fever
2. The Beginning Of The End
3. The Shape Of Things To Come
4. There is no place like home part1
5. The Constant
6. Meet Kevin Jonson
7. Confirmed Dead
8. Something Nice Back Home
9. The Economist
10. The Other Woman
11. Ji Yeon
12. Eggtown

[TheRadioTower]

According to DarkUFO episode table:

[Stephen]

According to DarkUFO episode table:

(You can't hotlink images from Blogger, so I have rehosted it here. Or at least I can't see it.)

Honestly, I don't think there are tens of thousands of people who visit that guys site to vote, but maybe it's just I don't like the site too much. Especially with such round numbers.

[You-Know-Who]

I think "The Other Woman" is very unfairly rated on darkufo's site. I don't think it's the greatest episode ever, but I definitely don't think it deserves to be that low on the list.

[You-Know-Who]

updated 5/30/08...

1 No Place Like Home (Parts 2-3)
2 The Shape of Things to Come
3 Cabin Fever
4 Confirmed Dead
5 The Constant
6 No Place Like Home (Part 1)
7 Meet Kevin Johnson
8 The Beginning of the End
9 The Economist
10 Something Nice Back Home
11 The Other Woman
12 Ji Yeon
13 Eggtown

David, how do you figure "Confirmed Dead" being above "The Constant"? Are you just not big fan of the time-travel stuff?
In my opinion The Constant was a serious blow-your-mind episode, Confirmed Dead was a very good episode but it can't match The Constant in mind-blowingness. By the way our list's are very similar... :)

[Vince]

1.Cabin Fever (b/c of the mind blowing paradigm shit re/ Locke, Jacob, Ben, Alpert and the overall mythology)
2.The Constant (I forgive weak science fiction for the amazing Desmond & Penny chapter. Great acting, directing, music, editing, writing - Wow!)
3.There's No Place Like Home, pts. 2&3 (obvious reasons)
4.The Shape of Things to Come (luv me some Ben story)
5.There's No Place Like Home, pt. 1 (great set-up for pts. 2 & 3)
6.Eggtown (I know I'm in the minority on this, but: a)Jack's testimony told us the most we'd heard about The Oceanic Six's story; b)great Ben & Miles scene; c)great lines from Sawyer and Hurley("you'll find a reason to be pissed at Jack and come bouncin' back to me," "you just totally Scooby Doo'd me, didn't you?"); d)the Aaron reveal; e)the grenade!!
7.The Economist (the Sayid/Ben story didn't excite me like it seemed do for everyone else)
8.Confirmed Dead (interesting introduction of the freighties)
9.The Beginning of The End (not bad but a li'l weak for a season opener)
10.Meet Kevin Johnson (another '3 Minutes')
11.Ji Yeon (love the gimmick of split flashes but the Jin flashback bore no relevance to the larger story)
12.Something Nice Back Home (meh)
13.The Other Woman (even though the Ben/Juliet scenes are very good, I hate the contrived Tempest story!)

[Justin]

I've been watching season 4 again, and I stand by my list... The early episodes are really good. "The Constant" is overrated (although still a good episode), and "The Other Woman" season 3 b-side though it may be, is underrated. Many of these episodes still work both on a dramatic level, and because many if not most of the questions we had about them remain unanswered. All in all, it was a good season, much less painful to rewatch than season 3.

[David3]

updated 5/30/08...

1 No Place Like Home (Parts 2-3)
2 The Shape of Things to Come
3 Cabin Fever
4 Confirmed Dead
5 The Constant
6 No Place Like Home (Part 1)
7 Meet Kevin Johnson
8 The Beginning of the End
9 The Economist
10 Something Nice Back Home
11 The Other Woman
12 Ji Yeon
13 Eggtown

David, how do you figure "Confirmed Dead" being above "The Constant"? Are you just not big fan of the time-travel stuff?
In my opinion The Constant was a serious blow-your-mind episode, Confirmed Dead was a very good episode but it can't match The Constant in mind-blowingness. By the way our list's are very similar... :)

After rewatching all the DVDs, I'd probably switch those two and maybe even bump it to three. I actually really like timne travel, I just worry that if they continue to do it, the writers will mess something up and create paradoxes.